Thank goodness my parents filled my head with facts!

Every Saturday my daughter volunteers at a day care centre for the elderly. On weekends there is a reduced number of staff on duty and as she’s under 18 I was asked if I could accompany her. This I’m happy to do.

Last Saturday an elderly gentleman came in (let’s call him Brian) and sat down besides me and we got talking. When, during the course of the conversation, I told Brian I used to live in Karachi, he became very excited. As it turned out he used to work for a multi national and spent seven years in Karachi in the 1960s. Brian said that although he sometimes meets people from Pakistan he rarely meets anyone from Karachi. We then passed a pleasant hour or so chatting about the city we both knew and loved. He told me where he first used to live (not a million miles away from my childhood home) and where he subsequently moved to (not a million miles away from where my parents now live). Brian was very interested in hearing about all the places he used to frequent; were they still there, had they changed much? He asked about Elphinstone Street, a prestigious shopping area of Karachi in those days. He asked if the tram still ran. He wanted to know if Maripur Road was still the main road in the city. He talked about his trip to Lyalpoor, a city in Punjab.  If my parents had not filled my head with facts, if I did not have knowledge of the old Karachi, I would have had to say,”I don’t know” to all his questions; Elphinstone Street is now Zaibunnissa Street and the tram service was discontinued years ago. Maripur Road is no longer the main road. In fact, I can’t remember if I’ve ever driven or be driven down Maripur Road. Lyalpoor is now called Faisalabad. Yes, I could have googled these places and worked out that I did know them albeit by a different name but that would have involved retrieving my bag from where I had stored it, taking my phone out and then typing these names in. I’m sure if that’s what I had done then the animated conversation Brian and I had would not have happened, for stopping every two minutes to goggle stuff is not conducive to chatting over coffee and biscuits! So, I am really glad my parents filled my head of facts about the history of the city they call home because these facts helped me connect with this elderly gentleman.

Lovely architecture, Elphinstone Street (now called Zaibunnissa Street). This is a very old building and Brain would have seen it when he lived in Karachi.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

We can be many things!

The above picture is doing the rounds on Twitter. I assume people who like it think it shows empowering girls or that it’s a feminist statement. As far as I’m concerned it’s nothing of the sort!

Let’s look at the logo first. “Forget princess” Why? What message does this give a girl who does want to dress up as a princess? Is this the equivalent of the dumb blond jokes? Is this saying to little girls that if you want to dress up as a princess then you are somehow inferior to someone who wants to be an astrophysicist? Is it so hard to imagine a little girl who loves dressing up as Cinderella AND wants to be an astrophysicist? Does it have to be one or the other? Would it not have been better to just have “I want to be an astrophysicist” as the slogan?

Secondly, does being a feminist mean we should only aim to have highly academic education/careers? What if the slogan was “I want to be a Reception teacher, a TA, a paramedic” or, shock, horror, “a mother”?! Are any of these choices in any way inferior? But I bet you if the slogan had said I want to be a mother there would have been outrage on social media! Some people may say that these are objectionable because there aren’t equivalent ones for boys. Two wrongs don’t make a right; let’s have a range for girls AND boys which make it ok to say that I want to be a father/mother and the others I’ve mentioned above.

Now, let’s look at the picture. Am I the only one who feels slightly uncomfortable looking at the picture of a little girl who, with those outsized sunglasses, looks to be older than what her age may be. So, little girls putting on huge sunglasses and looking older than their age is ok as long as they’re saying “Forget Princess”? 

My other objection to this slogan is that it turns dressing up as a princess from something that is innocent and age appropriate to something which is somehow wrong. My earliest memory of buying a book is from when I was 5 or 6. My father picked me up from school to take me to the dentist. On our way there he promised that once I’d been seen by the dentist he would take me to a book shop which was next door to the dental clinic and I could buy a book. I spent the time at the dentist thinking of the books I wanted to buy. We then went next door and I went from one shelf to another and finally settled on “Sleeping Beauty”. My daughters have loved dressing up and I’ve bought every Disney princess costume there has been! I went on to study Applied Genetics, my eldest is studying medicine, my middle daughter is applying to medicine and my youngest told me the other day that she really likes physics! Yes, a very small sample size and yes, anecdotal evidence but reading about and dressing up as a princess hasn’t harmed any of us. Let little girls be little girls and if they want to dress up as a princess then let them.  Now, that really is feminism!

As far as the above ad is concerned, I’ve fixed it for you!

Because

“Women have to be allowed to be many things.” – Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

An afternoon in the Orangerie. When experts stand at the front and #JustTellThem with passion

The people I follow on Twitter are mostly educators but I do follow some others as well. One such person is the author Alexandria Szeman. Every Saturday Alexandria chooses one painter and tweets their work. On 4th March 2017 the artist she featured was Anna Boch who was a Belgian Impressionist (1848-1936). Anna Boch was a name I was not familiar with. I loved all the paintings Alexandria tweeted (you can see them here). Alexandria and I started chatting about impressionists and as Monet is my all time favourite we started talking about him. The National Gallery in London has quite a few Monets and whenever I go to the Gallery I make a point to go to the rooms where these are displayed. I then told Alexandria about the other place I visited in order to see Monet’s work; the Musee de L’Orangerie in Paris.

After Alexandria and I finished chatting I started thinking of the time I had been to Paris and had visited the museum. On a previous visit I had visited the Louvre and I also knew about Musee d’Orsay. The trip during which I had visited Louvere hadn’t been for the express purpose of going there. I happened to find myself in Paris and thought since I was in Paris with a free afternoon I should go and see the Mona Lisa. So I did. The trip to Musee de L’Orangerie was different. This was a trip I planned for the sole purpose of going to the Orangerie.

You must be wondering where I am going with this. Bear with me, it will become clear. As I said I did not know a place like Musee de L’Orangerie even existed. The first time I heard about it was when I attended a lecture at my daughter’s school. The lecture was delivered by Professor Anthony Slinn. Professor Slinn has spent over 30 years lecturing and now gives over 200 presentatons a year. Professor Slinn is an exceptional speaker. He stood at the front, facing his audience (we were sat in rows!). He enthralled us with his wit and intelligence and his meticulously researched presentation. You could hear the passion in his voice. He told us about Monet and we listened. He brought the topic to life. Though I love impressionists and especially Monet, I would never have gone to Paris just to visit the Orangerie if it had not been for Professor Slinn. And why did I do that? Because I was listening to someone who is an expert, someone who is passionate about his subject. And sitting there, “passively” listening to him, I became passionate too. Many people think that when teachers stand at the front and “just tell” their students it must be a boring experience for the students. Not so. If the teacher is an expert and passionate about their subject then this “just telling” stuff makes students passionate too; passionate enough to jump on the Eurostar and spend the afternoon in the Musee de L’Orangerie

The video below doesn’t do jsutice to the exhibit but it may give you an idea of the treassure that was awaiting me in the Orangerie because a passionate expert transmitted his passion to me.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Six habits of highly successful students, thanks to @AceThatTest and @J_MedinaUML

I came across a series of tweets on six habits of highly successful students by J Medina  I thought I’d collate them in a blog so I and others can easily refer to them when needed.

Link to the video which explains the above six habits.

Link to all the Learning Scientists’ videos

Link to Learning Scientists website.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

My hopes for diversity in the education profession; a blog for @BAMEedNetwork

id-100376339

Image courtesy of lekkyjustdoit at FreeDigitalPhotos.net

The term diversity means something which signifies a range of different things, an assortment, a mixture etc. When we speak of diversity, we are referring to respecting the individual, we are referring to the uniqueness of each individual, we are referring to our individual differences but most importantly we are referring to acceptance of the individual. This acceptance also entails respecting and valuing the individual.

Diversity, equality and equity are interlinked. We are almost two decades into the 21st century but diversity, equality and equity still needs discussion and addressing. These are complex issues and there are no easy answers because we have only scratched the surface of the issue and haven’t even formulated all the questions yet. The best way to promote and celebrate a diverse society is through education and to do this, the profession needs to start by promoting diversity within itself.

These issues are complex and hence there will be no easy solutions or quick fixes. People sometimes put forward the idea of quotas to increase diversity. Again, we need to be very careful before introducing quotas. Baroness Doreen Lawrence was on an expert panel at the Charles Street Building, Sheffield Institute of Education, last year. One of the questions posed to the panel and audience concerned the attainment gap of BAME university students. The audience were asked to vote for one of the below which they felt should be the first action in addressing this.

  • Amend staff recruitment policies so staff are representative of the wider population
  • Accept that evidence suggests there is institutional racism and take measures to address it
  • Set up strong transition and progression routes and genuine aspirational pathways
  • Set BAME student recruitment quotas

Looking at the above four choices, which one do you think got the least votes?

Option 4 got the least number of votes (6%). Baroness Lawrence, too, said she did not agree with quotas and would go for Option 3 (which happened to be the one with the most votes). I also think that quotas are perhaps the wrong way to solve the diversity problem. One problem with quotas is that once you start a quota system and meet the quota, there may be a tendency to relax and think the problem has been solved.

So, what are my hopes for diversity in education?  I would like to have an education system where every individual is allowed to and has the resources and opportunities to access all that they need to in order to excel. I would like barriers removed so that more men feel they can go into teaching at early years and primary level, women feel they can go for leadership positions, every student (regardless of race, ethnicity, gender, income) has access to higher and further education. I would like us to really examine issues such as why people from disadvantaged white British backgrounds are least likely to access higher education and why female Bangladeshi graduates are less likely to be managers or professionals than male Bangladeshi graduates. I hope that equality, equity and diversity are promoted by treating by EVERYONE fairly. I hope there is equal access for everyone in all fields. I hope that we can help EVERYONE fight discrimination. I hope we will create environments where everyone can have a say; where people can speak up if they have been discriminated against, where people won’t be afraid to speak up thinking they may be thought of sexist, racist, etc. I hope that as a first step

“If we cannot now end our differences, at least we can help make the world  safe for diversity.” John F Kennedy

And in order to do that

“What we have to do…is to find a way to celebrate our diversity and debate our differences without fracturing our communities.” Hillary Clinton

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Cultural Knowledge.

The below passages are taken from Lord Edgware Dies by Agatha Christie.

Chapter 25 A Luncheon Party

Captain Hastings

Somebody—I forgot who—had uttered the phrase ‘judgement of Paris’, and straight away Jane’s delightful voice was uplifted. ‘Paris?’ she said. ‘Why, Paris doesn’t cut any ice nowadays. It’s London and New York that count.’ As sometimes happens, the words fell in a momentary lull of conversation.

It was an awkward moment. On my right I heard Donald Ross draw his breath sharply. Mrs Widburn began to talk violently about Russian opera. Everyone hastily said something to somebody else. Jane alone looked serenely up and down the table without the least consciousness of having said anything amiss.

Chapter 30 The Story

Hercule Poirot

It is at a luncheon party. Sir Montagu Corner makes a reference to a conversation he had with Lady Edgware on the night of the murder. That is easy. But Nemesis comes upon her later. There is a mention of the “judgement of Paris” and she takes Paris to be the only Paris she knows—the Paris of fashion and frills! ‘But opposite her is sitting a young man who was at the dinner at Chiswick—a young man who heard the Lady Edgware of that night discussing Homer and Greek civilization generally. Carlotta Adams was a cultured well-read girl. He cannot understand. He stares. And suddenly it comes to him. This is not the same woman. He is terribly upset. He is not sure of himself. He must have advice. He thinks of me. He speaks to Hastings. ‘But the lady overheard him. She is quick enough and shrewd enough to realize that in some way or other she has given herself away.

Reading Agatha Christie’s detective novels, especially those featuring Hercule Poirot was how I spent many pleasant days when young. Recent tweets about cultural literacy, ED Hirsch, classic lierature etc reminded me of the above passages. I think you can guess why!

Posted in Uncategorized | 3 Comments

PISA 2015: Analysis and blogs. 

Below, in no particular order, are blogs analysing the 2015 PISA results published today. If I’ve missed any, please let me know. 

Maybe the most relevant figure from PISA, imho by Pedro De Bruyckere

What America Can Learn About Smart Schools in Other Countries by Amanda Ripley

PISA results are in by Greg Ashman

The 10 key fundings from PISA by John Jerrim

PISA 2015: Initial analysis by Sam Freedman 

10 things you (probably) didn’t know about PISA by Nick Hassey

PISA 2015: No improvement for a decade … and 10 other oddities by Jess Staufenberg 

Long read: Does Pisa really tell us anything useful about schools? by William Stuart

PISA 2015: some tentative about successful teaching by David Didau

My top PISA takeaways by Stephen Tierney 

Royal Society comments on PISA 2015 UK science performance 

Pisa: ‘Surely the education debate being informed by evidence from more than one country is a good thing’ by Natalie Perera 

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment